Who's at fault in this whole sex photo scandal?

Discussion in 'Chinese Male Artists' started by hkm91450, Feb 2, 2008.


Who's at fault in this whole sex photo scandal?

  1. Edison

    31 vote(s)
  2. The Girls

    2 vote(s)
  3. Edison and the Girls

    24 vote(s)
  4. People who put the photos on the internet

    34 vote(s)
  5. Everyone is equally at fault

    34 vote(s)
  6. Other

    1 vote(s)
  7. No comment

    8 vote(s)
  1. hkm91450

    hkm91450 Well-Known Member

    #1 hkm91450, Feb 2, 2008
    Last edited: Dec 28, 2020
  2. Phil

    Phil 香港 PA 社團 揸Fap 人

    hmmm If the Pics were Real, Edison would be at Fault, but i think that sex is normal , i mean , everyone has needs =P so prob PPl who put on net are baddies
  3. strawberri_angelbaby

    strawberri_angelbaby Well-Known Member

    i feel bad for the singers too, but i can't really say it's Edison's fault just cause he went to the united states and i'm not supporting him either. it's just hard to point fingers at a person when only the people who put those pictures is only at fault because who would actually want to do that o_O and we dont' know the whole issue here. that's why i say it would be the people who put the pictures on the internet.
  4. xmichelly

    xmichelly Well-Known Member

    its edison & the girls
  5. Phil

    Phil 香港 PA 社團 揸Fap 人

    lol do u think the Girls knew or something lol, well some of them prob knew but some of them didnt know =P
  6. lee-lee

    lee-lee Well-Known Member

    gosh, is this STILL the biggest news?! ugh...if the pics were real, then all involved are to blame. from edison to the girls. don't want shit like this to happen to u? then don't pull shit like this. end of discussion. in this day and age with the way technology is, nothing will be kept undercovers. sooner or later, it's gonna get into the wrong hands. so don't boo-hoo to the world if u were that DUMB to do crap like that.
    and if it's not true....quite obviously the blame is on the guy who put all this together.
  7. hiake

    hiake Vardøgr of da E.Twin

    I think everyone involved are at fault, to various degrees:

    Edison Chen: after all, up til this moment it is believed it was him who was the source of the photo... He didn't keep a secret safe = no good.

    the Girls: Anyone with a working brain should know better, and really, as xmichelly said, if the file exists, there's a chance it will be leaked... Now I am just remember how I read about "sex games" in Maxim, it recommended Polaroid as the medium to use (single copy, and easy to destroy) -lol Observe and learn, guys.

    the "evil" people: yes, Edison and the girls are stupid, but it doesn't mean that people who take advantage of their stupidity isn't to blame for this mess. At the moment, the most updated story I have is that Edison was BLACKMAILED before the photos were uploaded... So I guess they meant malice and that's a no no.

    Bonus: the media. The media blew the whole thing out of proportion and hype it up so much that this piece of new got a life of its own, now it's up to anyone's guess how it should turn out...
  8. khaotic

    khaotic Fobulous

    I don't see why everyone is just blindly blaming Edison. Is it his fault that the photos were taken (if real)? Yes

    But it wasn't his fault that the girls were stupid enough to agree with it.

    But as hiake say the media are just being a bunch a bitches. Making accusations here and there, without any evidence to back anything up. They're also putting a bad image on Edison (not saying I don't agree with it). Even though the female stars are as much to blame for it. :\

    Everyone is to blame... If you can't deal with the fact your fav stars made a mistake then w/e.. Just don't go randomly putting the blame on one single person.
  9. mr_evolution

    mr_evolution ( • )( •ԅ(ˆ⌣ˆԅ)

    I voted everyone also. If the photos were real, everyone in the photos should know in their position, photos like these WILL be leaked out eventually. And the people who uploaded these photos are at fault as well as it is illegal.
  10. I dunno.. some say might be rival record company that set all this up..

    but I'm still shocked about this whole thing now that even more pictures surfaced..
  11. BestOffer

    BestOffer Well-Known Member

    everyone at fault! if one posted those photos online and "they" [the 8 ppl] not interested, it won't have such a great effect...is all about the ppl spreading out the words...and in reply to the photos, is not RARE to have those pics from a cell phone...these are very common these days (just don't understand why capture urself have ur dick suck by the female or other scenery)
  12. jdm_s2k

    jdm_s2k Well-Known Member

    i think they all should be responsible...because one...they let edison take the pics....and two....they should be prepared...like this...to happen...
  13. amoureux

    amoureux Active Member

    yeah i guess if the girls involved knew that they were being flimed, it means consensus by both parties right? they were stupid enough to let their acts be taken.. unless they really do not know.

    however i think the girls are still more pitiful as compared to Edison.. i wonder how are the invovled ones going to clarify or deny.
  14. SUSIE-DANG-1988


    EVERYONE to blame!!!

    geez, i don't care anymore. This news is getting boring now.
  15. SunnyD

    SunnyD Member

    heard there are new pics released...
  16. natnat528

    natnat528 Active Member

    i can't believe how much Edison is getting blamed for this scandal! I just read an article saying that many people online voted that edison should be sent to jail! I just can't get over these extreme reactions to Edison.

    Why is everyone saying that only the females are the victims? If the pictures are fake then Edison AND the female celebs are victims. If the pictures are indeed real and the female stars knew about them being taken then they should take a share of the blame too. I just hate the fact that there are some people out there who blindly believe in the whole 'innocent act' of their idols and then use Edison as a scapegoat to protect the reputation of the female celebrities.

    There is nothing wrong with consenting adults having sex or taking pictures such as the ones in the scandal. The only reason why this has become such a big deal is because of the status of the people involved and also the fact that some people claimed that they were fake. I don't understand why Gillian's company still maintain that the pictures are fake and saying how proud they are of Gillian. What is there to be proud of? She has just refused to turn up to any public events and stayed at home. To me, that doesnt seem like being strong. So why is Edison being criticised for leaving HK but Gillian is 'strong' for staying at home... it just frustates me so much!

    In my opinon, the people who uploaded the pictures in the first place are worse than Edison and the female stars!
  17. -Tisken-

    -Tisken- Well-Known Member

    itZz edisons fault, because she shouldnt put the photos on the laptop... i mean, sex with other girls is ok, as long as it is top secret... i still dont know why he took the pics...
  18. frostshards

    frostshards Well-Known Member

    wheres theo ption for the people who uploaded the pictures and edisno are at fault. edison is at fault because he forgot t delete the picturse from his comp b4 taking it for repair. the uploaders are at fault because they shouldnt have infringed on edison's privacy.
  19. shadowchi

    shadowchi ~~♫ ♫ ♪ Himitsu ♪ ♫ ♫ ~~

    It's the digital camera seller's fault, he should have sold him a camera -lol

    uhhmm, I think it's the girls fault.
    If they didn't let edison take pictures of them, this wouldn't happend.

    edison's fault.
    He should have deleted the photo's when the relationship ended.
    - He is rich, he could buy a new PC. So why did he let it repair, i guess he didn't have a backup of the pictures? -whistle

    Media, and the perverted people (men). If they didn't uplouded this and if they didn't published it, it would have this big impact.
  20. 小Yu咒

    小Yu咒 ♪♪♫很可愛~♥

    Off topic: yeah..and they look very real...even the tattoos from cecilia and the mark spot from gillian or was it bobo..still could be photoshopped..
    You can watch or DL very realistic pics from www.theblemish.com. But beware of spam!!
    I think its very sick of Edison..and really stupid of the girls..some of them looks a bit high? Poor girls, sighs.

    On topic:
    And yet no one to blame for it, but himself..especially when theres no proof of evidence that the criminals where trying too get money of this..
    uploading illegal pictures and so on..who doesnt do it..but still no one goes to jail for that..and i dont even mention movies ;]