Help me pick a DSLR camera! Canon Rebel XS or Nikon D40 (or D60)?

Discussion in 'Science, Technology & Car Chat' started by KT, Oct 21, 2008.

  1. KT

    KT H E L L O K T ♥

    1,601
    374
    46
    Ok, so I decided I want to get a DSLR now.. I'm planning on taking photography next semester and so I wanna figure out what camera I want to convince my parents to buy for me. (I've already succeeded half way hahahaha.. just gotta tell them which one I want) So help me!

    Canon Rebel XS, Nikon D40, or maybe the D60..
     
  2. runtohell121

    runtohell121 ........................

    3,239
    463
    107
    pfft.. get a Canon Xsi or XTI or the Nikon D60... lol
     
  3. Canon!! their stuff is great.....
     
  4. Aoes

    Aoes Well-Known Member

    errrr isn't like the first photo class using 35mm cameras? o_O

    either is fine, u'll probably get more support community wise from the rebel group though =/
     
  5. oh shit, kates is baller... getting a dslr.... even i can't get one... lol
     
  6. bbes

    bbes Incredible

    same i don't have one either lol. but yea canon tends to be quite gd and so are nikon rele. depends what ur taking pictures mostly on. if it is people, canon tends to have the edge whereas with landscapes then nikon has the edge. but if ur getting the nikon get d60, it is much better than the d40 i hear.
     
  7. fearless_fx

    fearless_fx Eugooglizer

    im thinking between the Canon XS and D60.

    The D40 isn't worth the money imo, its pretty low end compared to the D60, even if you get the D40X with 10 MP.

    Iv played around with the Canon XSi, XS and D60 so far and id have to say the XSi impresses me the most, both in terms of how it feels and how much tech it has. Buuuut my budget is a bit too low for the XSi, so im leaning towards the XS, mainly cuz it has a liveview LCD which would be kinda nice, and because it has alot of new tech for a fairly reasonable price.
    If you want to read up on DSLR's http://www.dcresource.com has a ton of solid reviews, id definitely check it out before hand, cuz a DSLR is a pretty big cash purchase.

    I was planning on buying one before christmas, but now my holiday plans have kinda fallen apart, so i might wait till summer... hopefully by then the pricing will go down a bit more.

    Id probably also take a close look at lens prices too... if your doing a pro photography class you're probably going to need macro lenses for sure, as well as different filters and stuff, so id see whether nikon or canon are cheaper in terms of that stuff.
     
  8. kontradictions

    kontradictions Well-Known Member

    Try them both. Actually go out and hold them and see which feels more comfortable in your hands. That's the one that you should consider.
     
  9. reno

    reno Well-Known Member

    i still prefer nikon :p

    and d40 is now kinda officially "discontinued"
    so if u see any, it'd be cheap cheap =)

    go d90 =D
    live view and hd video!! lol
     
  10. KT you are so spoiled......=\
     
  11. bbes

    bbes Incredible

    i know she is ridiculously spoiled. i remember her talking about a new digital camera a few months back lol.
     
  12. lol having a dslr would be sick, but honestly, you can pull off an A+ with a high end point and shoot with manual features worth 300, and save yourself an investment of over a thousand dollars on a dslr + lenses + equipment.


    some people take better pictures with a point and shoot than novices with a dslr, proves that dslr doesn't make your pic nicer.
     
  13. its more like..... the novices just doesn't know the basics of making a picture look nice
     
  14. ok fine... nonetheless, novices should practice on point and shoots before taking on dslrs
     
  15. and i wholeheartedly agree.... KT go to CVS and get a disposable one to practice with first.... LOL -whistle
     
  16. LOL!!!

    naw man... don't be mean... katie, go for a canon point and shoot, make sure it has a manual function that allows you to change aperture, exposure and ISO at the least.

    If you really need super zoom, get a point and shoot which supports telephoto lens add-on, or just go for a high zoom camera with said features above to begin with...
     
  17. runtohell121

    runtohell121 ........................

    3,239
    463
    107
    ooooo she is more spoiled than me o_O? :laugh2:

    get the Nikon D60 or Canon XSI and call it the end already :p
     
  18. Crystal84

    Crystal84 Well-Known Member

    245
    41
    0
    If you dont want mess with all the funtions a dslr has, then go for a Canon G9 or Canon G10. The Quality is as good as a DSLR and its more userfriendly.

    If you really want a DSLR I only can recommend you the Canon 40D (dont know if there is a different name in US). Since the 50D was released last month, the prices for the 40d dropped to a very low price. It provides you with all the functions which beginners and semi pro users need.

    But as the other guys said before, a DSLR DOES NOT make better photos. Actually you will get really bad ones at the beginning and this can carry on for like a year or so until you learn the basics of using a DSLR. And BEFORE you learn the basics, you need to learn which motiv is worth to take a photo of.

    Depending on how much your parents are willing to spent for your first DSLR they will suffer later on ^^. If they spent the minimum for a DSLR, then they will pay lot of after a couple of month because you wont be satisfied with the basic equipment.
    If I were you I will buy a G9 or a G10 to learn the basics. DSLR overkills most of their users with a bunch of functions they never use. And buying such a expensive camera and shooting in Automatic mode is stupid ;)


    UPDATE: Just checked the cameras you wanted to buy, I wouldnt go for any of them because they don´t worth the money. You will reach the edge of these cameras really fast and the photo qualitiy isnt that good.
     
  19. KT

    KT H E L L O K T ♥

    1,601
    374
    46
    I am NOT spoiled.. :shifty: haha. I am still searching.. Keep to recommendations coming..

    btw.. ok I know I can use a point and shoot, and that's the only thing I've been using, but I WANT a DSLR.. so thanks for the suggestion, but no thanks. -rotfl
     
  20. LOL... kates.... want vs need....

    want will make you, or your parents, pay at the very least over a thousand dollars... if not a few... while remaining a noob photographer lol


    i'm just going to break it down:

    First entry level DSLR (BODY ONLY) = $600 at the least
    35mm lens (basic) = $200 minimum
    bag/accessories and all that shit (flash, tripod, filters) = $100 for shit ones

    plus tax and all, $1100.

    then, you're gonna hate it, because it wont do what you want it to do.

    Second DSLR (Body only) = $1300
    2 lenses (your reg 35mm, and another super zoom lens) = $600
    bag/accessories = $200 for good quality shit

    total for the second package, $2500 plus taxes, and total up both packages, $3600.



    ORRR you can just get a d40, a shit lens, and just go take point and shoot pictures. $600.



    if it were me, i'd stick with my baller point and shoot. but hey, if a dlsr makes you cool, then by all means, get the best of the best ;)